Saturday, November 21, 2026

The Greatest Movie Never Made

 Hard agree.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Sailing With O'Brian

The Book Club podcast with Tabitha Syrett and Dominic Sandbrook (from The Rest is History) has a brilliant episode on Master And Commander, the first book of the Aubrey-Maturin series of twenty novels brilliantly written by Patrick O'Brian.  I first read the series between 1991 and 2000 and did a second read over six months in 2020.  I plan to conduct a third expedition in 2030.  

The podcasters eloquently explain how O'Brian created (or recreated) a unique world, that of the British Navy during the Napoleonic era by writing as if he was an observer in the early 1800s, using the jargon of that era, the complex sailing lingo, and the mental attitudes of the early 19th century.  The author makes no attempt to interject late 20th century attitudes into the narrative.  Syrett and Sandbrook make reference several times to O'Brian's stylistic resemblance to Jane Austen and a commentator describes the books as "Jane Austen for Boys", and the excerpts they quote gave you a wonderful flavor for O'Brian's writing.

The podcasters give the best advice for we non-sailors, which is to let the sailing lingo wash over you without being concerned about fully understanding it because, at its heart, the novels are about Aubrey and Maturin's friendship and the community formed on a naval vessel. 

Along the way, they explore the mystery of who Patrick O'Brian really was.  When the novels were republished in the US in the late 1980s and achieved massive success, twenty years after O'Brian began the series, he granted an interview to the New York Times in which everything he said about his background was a lie.  It is only in more recent years that we've learned his real name and more about his life before fame.  

The podcast also touches on the real life model for Jack Aubrey, a subject on which I've previously written (see Capturing Esmeralda: The Real Jack Aubrey).

There is nothing else in historical fiction that approaches the all-encompassing world created by O'Brian.  Both times I've completed the series I am left with a feeling of loss that I could not continue with two of my favorite people in literature.  I look forward to my third voyage with them.  

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Six Minutes

 Ran across this very good, and brief, summary of the Battle of Midway (June 4-7, 1942) which turned the tide in America's favor during the war against Japan.  It was a close run thing that could have easily gone wrong for us.  The work of the code breakers at Pearl Harbor, the willingness of Admirals Nimitz and Spruance to risk their only carriers, and the bravery and sacrifice of those on Midway and of the carrier air crews, all contributed to the victory.

The U.S. committed its last three carriers in the Pacific to the battle, while Japan had four carriers present.  The initial American attacks fared poorly.  In six attacks, 83 aircraft, B-17s along with dive and torpedo  bombers failed to score a hit on any enemy ships with most of the aircraft shot down and the crews lost.

Then, at 10:25 on the morning of June 4, 30 dive bombers from USS Enterprise and 17 from USS Yorktown, all running low on fuel. found the Japanese carriers.  Within six minutes, three carriers - Soryu, Akagi, and Kaga - were on fire and all eventually sank.  Perhaps the most decisive six minutes of the Second World War.  Later that afternoon, dive bombers from Enterprise found and struck Hiryu, the last of Japan's carriers, which sank the following morning.

One of the aspects of the video I enjoyed is that it exclusively uses footage shot during the battle, much of it by director John Ford, who was on Midway and wounded in the Japanese attack on the island.  He had a few days earlier taken the footage of the ill-fated crew of Torpedo Squadron 8, which lost 29 of 30 men in the attack on the carriers.  For more on Ford and the other Hollywood directors who volunteered to make films to support the war effort read Five Came Back.

The remainder of 1942 still contained dark and dangerous days for America and its allies in the Pacific; at one point late that year the Enterprise was the operational carrier available in the theater, but the loss of the four carriers and a large cadre of its experienced pilots, crippled the Japanese war effort, and bought time for America's industrial might to come into play with a flood of carriers, submarines, and other naval vessels beginning to flood into the Pacific during 1943.

By the time of the invasion of Okinawa in April 1945, the U.S. fielded the largest fleet the world had every seen.  At Midway, Admiral Nimitz deployed almost every available asset, scraping together 3 carriers, 8 cruisers, and 15 destroyers, along with 360 aircraft (including the 127 based on Midway).  At Okinawa, the US fleet totaled more than 1,300 vessels, including 39 fleet, light, and escort carriers, 18 battleships, 32 cruisers, 177 destroyers, 103, minesweepers, 49 fleet oilers, and 1,900 aircraft. 

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Tomorrow Is A Long Time

Yes, and only if my own true love was waitin' 
Yes, and if I could hear her heart a-softly poundin' 
Only if she was lyin' by me 
Then I'd lie in my bed once again 
There's beauty in the silver, singin' river 
There's beauty in the sunrise in the sky 
But none of these and nothing else can touch the beauty 
That I remember in my true love's eyes
One of Bob Dylan's finest love songs as well as an example of the odd chronology of his recorded releases.  Dylan originally recorded a demo of Tomorrow Is A Long Time in December 1962, very early in his career, and the only version he ever released is from a concert on April 12, 1963 but which was not released until 1971 on the album Bob Dylan's Greatest Hits Vol. II.
 
By the time Dylan released his version, the song had been covered by eleven artists on recordings, including Judy Collins, Odetta, Ian & Sylvia, The Kingston Trio, Rod Stewart, and Elvis Presley.
 
I think Dylan's original is better than any of the covers, which is often not the case.  

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Bad Start

"What a disappointment the twentieth century has been.  How terrible and melancholy is the long series of disastrous events, which have darkened its first twenty years.  We have seen in every country a dissolution, a weakening of bonds, a challenge to these principles, a decay of faith, an abridgement of hope, on which the structure and ultimate existence of civilized society depends."

 Winston Churchill, November 11, 1922  

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

The Gales Of November

I probably would not have read The Gales of November: The Untold Story of the Edmund Fitzgerald, John Bacon's account on the sinking of the Great Lakes freighter on November 10, 1975, published last year, but for the rave recommendation received from a friend because I felt I already knew as much as I wanted to know about the tragedy.  My friend was right.

Bacon does a remarkable job balancing the historical, technical, and, above all, the human aspects of the story.  While he does write of the various theories about why the Fitzgerald sank it is not his primary focus.  I learned much about the economic origins of the Great Lakes trade, the dangers of those water particularly Superior, and the technical issues of ship design.  He also tells the personal stories of those who sailed on the Fitzgerald's last voyage, along with their families and of the harrowing details (at least as much as we can know) of what happened 51 years ago, as well as of the investigations after the sinking.  Once the Fitzgerald starts its voyage I found myself hoping against hope for a better outcome, despite knowing the inevitable conclusion.

The author also devotes attention to what the families have done since 1975 to preserve the memories of their loved ones and of Gordon Lightfoot's composing of The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald.  

There was so much more to the story, at every level, than I had realized.  For a start I had not known about the renown of the Edmund Fitzgerald, considered the best of the Great Lakes freighters even before the tragedy which is why it resonated so much with the shipping community.

A very moving tale, exceptionally well told.

And now I recommend it to you. 

Book cover for 'The Gales of November: The Untold Story of the Edmund Fitzgerald' by John U. Bacon, New York Times Bestseller. Features a dramatic painting of a large cargo ship battling stormy seas at night.